The Bella Twins have recently ignited widespread excitement among wrestling enthusiasts by publicly sharing their ambitious vision for a potential revival of the groundbreaking reality series Total Divas. During a candid conversation on SiriusXM, the iconic duo meticulously detailed which WWE superstars they would strategically invite to join them in a hypothetical reboot, carefully balancing nostalgic favorites from the show's original run with fresh, dynamic faces from today's vastly different roster. Their thoughtful selections reveal not only their deep understanding of reality television dynamics but also their continued finger on the pulse of WWE's evolving women's division.
Total Divas originally premiered on the E! network in 2013 and quickly transcended its initial premise to become a genuine cultural phenomenon that extended far beyond the typical wrestling audience. While the show concluded its impressive nine-season run in 2019, its influence continues to resonate powerfully throughout the professional wrestling world and mainstream entertainment landscape. What began as a simple peek behind the curtain of WWE's women's division evolved into a revolutionary platform that humanized larger-than-life athletes and showcased their complex personal struggles, intricate relationships, and ambitious career goals outside the squared circle. The series demonstrated that these powerful women were multi-dimensional individuals with compelling stories worth telling.
The series proved particularly impactful for inspiring the next generation of female wrestlers who now dominate WWE programming. Current roster members including Chelsea Green, Maxxine Dupri, and numerous others have openly credited Total Divas as the primary catalyst that sparked their childhood dreams of joining WWE. This profound generational impact highlights how reality television can serve as an unexpectedly powerful recruitment tool, making the wrestling world feel accessible and aspirational to young viewers who might never have considered professional wrestling as a career path. The show's ability to showcase women balancing athletic careers with personal lives created role models that extended far beyond the ring.
As the undisputed cornerstones of the original series, Nikki and Brie Bella appeared in every single season alongside Natalya, forming the reliable core that anchored the show through numerous cast changes and dramatic shifts in WWE's corporate culture. Their authenticity and willingness to share both their triumphant victories and vulnerable setbacks made them relatable figures who transcended their wrestling personas to become genuine celebrities. When asked about their ideal reboot cast, the twins drew upon this deep historical knowledge while demonstrating a clear eye toward the future evolution of both the show and the industry.
The foundation of their dream roster would deliberately rest upon familiar faces who helped establish the show's identity and maintain its authenticity. Naomi, who appeared in the early seasons and has since evolved into one of WWE's most respected veterans, would bring her vibrant personality, incredible in-ring skills, and valuable perspective on longevity in the business. Natalya, the only other cast member to appear in all nine seasons alongside the Bellas, represents essential continuity and carries the prestigious Hart family legacy that adds gravitas to any project. Nia Jax, another former cast member who has been open about her unconventional path to wrestling, would add her unique perspective, outspoken nature, and body positivity advocacy to the mix. This trio of OGs would provide the nostalgic anchor that longtime fans would deeply appreciate while offering crucial mentorship to newer cast members navigating the complexities of reality fame.
For the fresh blood that would drive new storylines, the Bellas specifically named three rising stars who perfectly embody the show's spirit of ambition and authenticity. Maxxine Dupri, currently managing Alpha Academy on Monday Night Raw, has already demonstrated natural charisma and remarkable comfort in front of cameras despite her relative inexperience. Her journey from professional cheerleader to wrestling manager showcases the type of career evolution that makes compelling reality television, particularly her navigation of backstage politics and performance pressure. Chelsea Green, with her multiple WWE stints, independent circuit experience, and reality TV background from her time on MTV, brings a resilient story of perseverance that viewers would find deeply inspiring. Her recent return to the company and subsequent push toward championship contention creates natural dramatic stakes that would translate perfectly to the reality format.
Perhaps most intriguingly, the twins singled out Tiffany Stratton as an ideal newcomer who represents the future of WWE. The former NXT standout has quickly established herself as one of the company's most promising young talents, blending exceptional athleticism with her privileged character background that could create fascinating storylines about entitlement versus earned success. Her "daddy's little rich girl" persona, contrasted with the genuine hard work and physical punishment required to succeed in wrestling, would provide the type of compelling narrative arcs that made the original series so addictive to mainstream audiences.
Beyond these core selections, Nikki and Brie expressed particular curiosity about two of WWE's biggest current stars who exist on the periphery of traditional wrestling narratives. Jade Cargill, the former AEW TBS Champion who recently made her highly anticipated WWE debut, intrigues the twins with her mysterious aura and unprecedented rapid ascent through the ranks. Her transition from successful fitness model and business owner to dominant wrestling champion represents exactly the type of transformation that Total Divas excels at documenting, particularly the challenges of adapting to WWE's unique culture. Similarly, Rhea Ripley, the reigning Women's World Champion and cornerstone of The Judgment Day faction, captured their interest due to her unique gothic lifestyle, unconventional relationship dynamics, and commanding presence that defies traditional femininity. Ripley's unapologetic authenticity would offer viewers a stark contrast to more traditional wrestling personalities and expand the show's representation.
The Bellas' selections reveal a sophisticated understanding of what made Total Divas successful beyond simple drama. By mixing established veterans with hungry newcomers, they create a dynamic where multiple storylines can naturally intersect and evolve organically. The OGs provide wisdom, historical context, and stability, while the newer generation brings contemporary energy, social media savvy, and relatable struggles with modern issues like mental health and brand building. This deliberate blend ensures the reboot would appeal to both nostalgic fans of the original and younger viewers discovering these personalities for the first time through TikTok and Instagram.
The show's legacy extends far beyond mere entertainment value or ratings success. Total Divas played a crucial role in normalizing female wrestlers as multi-dimensional individuals rather than just athletic performers or eye candy. It showcased their entrepreneurial businesses, complex romantic relationships, difficult health struggles, and profound personal growth in ways that resonated with mainstream audiences who had never watched wrestling. This humanization helped pave the way for the women's evolution in WWE, where female athletes now headline major events like WrestleMania and receive equal billing to their male counterparts in marketing and compensation.
Moreover, the series demonstrated WWE's ability to create compelling content outside traditional wrestling programming, opening doors for subsequent reality projects like Total Bellas and Miz & Mrs. It proved that the personalities driving the in-ring action could be just as captivating in unscripted situations, creating additional revenue streams and brand extensions. The Bellas themselves parlayed their reality TV success into various business ventures, including their own wine label, clothing lines, and successful podcast, showing how the platform can launch careers far beyond wrestling and into mainstream celebrity.
While WWE has not officially announced any plans to revive Total Divas, the continued interest from its most famous stars and the current roster's enthusiasm suggests there remains significant untapped potential. The women's division is deeper, more athletic, and more diverse than ever before, with personalities spanning different backgrounds, body types, and character archetypes that would thrive in a reality setting. From established champions to emerging prospects, the roster offers a rich pool of potential cast members who could bring fresh perspectives to the format and attract new demographics.
The timing might also be uniquely opportune for a reboot. Reality television has evolved significantly since 2019, with audiences now expecting more authenticity, less manufactured drama, and greater diversity in storytelling. A new iteration could benefit from these changing tastes by offering a more genuine, warts-and-all look at the lives of modern wrestlers, who are increasingly open about mental health challenges, work-life balance difficulties, and the immense pressures of performing at the highest level while maintaining social media presence. The current generation of wrestlers is more media-trained yet paradoxically more authentic than their predecessors.
For dedicated fans, the Bellas' dream cast represents a perfect bridge between past and present, honoring the show's roots while acknowledging how much WWE has evolved in terms of women's athleticism and character depth. The inclusion of stars like Ripley and Cargill, who represent the current pinnacle of women's wrestling both in-ring and in terms of star power, would elevate the reboot beyond mere nostalgia into something that truly reflects today's landscape and future direction.
Ultimately, whether or not Total Divas returns to television screens, the conversation itself highlights the lasting impact of reality programming in professional wrestling and its power to shape careers. The Bella Twins' thoughtful casting choices demonstrate their deep understanding of both the entertainment business and the wrestling world they helped transform from within. Their vision serves as both a tribute to where they've been and a strategic roadmap for where the industry could go next, blending respect for legacy with bold innovation.